Authors: Enrico Forti (Seton Hall University); Alessandro Piazza (Rice University); Joost Rietveld (UCL School of Management)
Interviewers: Teagan Gahler (University of Derby); Jack Auslander (IESE Business School)
Article link: https://doi.org/10.1177/00018392251360671
Please tell us about the inception of the idea for this study. Was the idea mainly inspired by the press coverage and conversations surrounding the George Floyd protests? Or did you approach this idea from a more theoretical perspective?
Alessandro Piazza: This was our COVID project! It began during the lockdowns, as we watched the events surrounding CrossFit unfold in real time. My coauthor Joost Rietveld is an avid CrossFitter, so he was particularly tuned into what was happening and the debate within the CrossFit community. My recollection is that he and my other coauthor, Enrico Forti, originally had the idea and discussed it with me. There was an immediate practical consideration: we needed to collect the data quickly, particularly the gyms’ announcements that they intended to disaffiliate.
When they brought the idea to me, I was very interested, and my role became helping make sense of the phenomenon theoretically. I connected it to several questions that have long interested me: how communities shape organizational behavior, why firms take public stances on social issues, and how organizations respond to negative events.
So, on balance, the phenomenon came first. We were watching something happen and trying to understand it. The theoretical framing developed as we connected those observations to broader questions about firms and the communities in which they are embedded.
Community permeability is presented through network closure, segregation, and issue connectedness. Did you begin the project thinking of these as dimensions of a common theoretical idea, or did the concept of community permeability emerge as you worked through the empirical findings and review process?
Community permeability really came into focus through the review process. We were interested early on in community characteristics, particularly their structural features—structural in a network sense. But we did not begin with the fully developed framework you see in the published paper. The original submission considered a broader mix of community characteristics; by the first revision, we had brought network closure, segregation, and issue connectedness together.
The review process pushed us to make the theoretical framework more coherent. We had to ask ourselves: What do these things have in common? What do they do together? Our answer was that they shape how receptive a community is to social issues and debates that originate outside it.
That is how community permeability became the organizing idea, explicitly in the second revision. Network closure concerns connections across community boundaries; segregation concerns connections across segments within the community; and issue connectedness concerns ties to the particular communities affected by an issue. The underlying arguments were developing earlier, but the review process helped us explain why they belonged together.
You argue that network closure can insulate communities from external social issues by limiting their penetration. But once an issue does penetrate a highly closed community, could those same dense internal ties amplify the issue, accelerating a shared interpretation or response?
I think that is an interesting possibility. For issues that originate locally, the amplification mechanism makes a lot of sense to me, particularly given what we know about closure in the Coleman sense: dense ties can support trust and shared understandings. We raise that possibility in the paper’s discussion, although it is not something we test.
For outside issues, I think the question is more open. Our framework distinguishes between an issue penetrating a community and its acquiring meaning and significance there. Simply learning about an issue does not mean that people will regard it as their concern. There are so many things competing for everyone’s attention, and outside issues may struggle to achieve the resonance of something that feels specific to the community.
“Simply learning about an issue does not mean that people will regard it as their concern. There are so many things competing for everyone’s attention, and outside issues may struggle to achieve the resonance of something that feels specific to the community.”
But one can certainly imagine exceptions. National political issues, for example, can become closely connected to local identities and divisions, particularly at a time of extreme polarization. Once that happens, dense internal ties might reinforce a shared interpretation and amplify a response. That would be an interesting extension of the argument. I would present it as a possibility worth investigating, though, rather than a mechanism our study establishes.
Your theoretical model first theorizes community-level outcomes and subsequently on firm-level outcomes. Did you find it difficult to reconcile the two in one paper? How did the review process shape the way you connected these two outcomes – did reviewers at ASQ push you toward a different structure at any point?
Yes, although perhaps not quite in the way the question suggests. We started with community characteristics as predictors and firm behavior as the outcome. In fairly straightforward terms, we had community variables on the right-hand side and gyms’ announcements of their intention to disaffiliate from CrossFit on the left.
The editor and reviewers encouraged us to look more closely at what our arguments were actually saying. We were arguing that community characteristics make an issue more or less salient locally, and that greater salience then encourages organizational action. In other words, issue salience was already doing a lot of work in the theoretical explanation, but we had not given it a sufficiently explicit role in the model.
Once we thought about it that way, we recognized that we were describing a mediating pathway. I initially resisted making that move, partly because mediation can be difficult to handle convincingly with archival data. We spent quite a bit of time working through the theoretical and methodological implications, and I am happy with where we ended up. So the challenge was less about reconciling two disconnected outcomes than about clarifying the role of each element in the explanation. The connection was implicit in our reasoning; the review process helped us make it explicit and align the empirical analysis with it. That made for a better paper.
Your data captures a unique moment in time in which public discourse around social issues was heightened. How do you think your results generalize to today’s environment that has witnessed a general backlash to cancel culture and an “anti-woke” movement? Might community permeability operate differently when the social issue itself is deeply contested and segments of the same community form different expectations?
This is probably the hardest question, and it connects to some public writing I have done. In a recent article for The Conversation, I discuss how the political calculation surrounding corporate stance-taking has changed. The basic point is that stances are not free. Progressive positions once benefited from a relatively favorable asymmetry: they could attract approval from activists and employees without provoking equally organized opposition. That asymmetry has weakened, particularly as conservative actors have become more willing to punish corporate positions they oppose, including through government power.
“What has changed is the environment in which firms decide what to do about that attention. An issue can be highly salient among employees or customers while taking a public stance exposes the company to substantial costs elsewhere.”
My sense is that the underlying mechanisms in our paper still apply. Community structure should still help explain which outside issues attract local attention and acquire significance. What has changed is the environment in which firms decide what to do about that attention. An issue can be highly salient among employees or customers while taking a public stance exposes the company to substantial costs elsewhere. That creates stronger incentives for neutrality, cautious language, or less visible responses, although some companies may still act on their values.
I would also distinguish salience from agreement. Different segments of a community can care intensely about the same issue while expecting opposite responses from firms. Permeability does not necessarily produce consensus, and our study does not fully resolve how firms navigate those incompatible expectations.
At the same time, we should not assume that every contested issue produces two equally mobilized camps. Think of a proposed data center: one can imagine intense local opposition without an equally passionate constituency campaigning for it. Support may exist, but the intensity and organization of the two sides can be quite different.
So, I would expect community structure to remain relevant, while being cautious about assuming that the same level of issue salience will produce the same organizational response across political environments. Understanding when salience translates into action, hedging, or silence is an important next question.
Interviewer Bios:
Jack Auslander is a doctoral candidate in the Strategic Management Department at IESE Business School. His research investigates the consequences of creating formal positions to manage multiple organizational goals. He is currently writing a series of papers, each drawing on a different theoretical perspective, that examine how corporate sustainability managers come to champion socially oriented goals and shape organizational outcomes.
Teagan Gahler is a doctoral candidate at the University of Derby. Teagan’s research examines how leaders in Canadian polytechnic business schools navigate competing institutional demands in curriculum decision-making and industry engagement. Drawing on institutional logics and boundary spanning leadership, she explores how academic, market, and state expectations shape leadership practices, institutional legitimacy, and program-level decisions.
Get new ASQ Blog posts by email
